MJF secured the second entry into the Casino Gauntlet match at AEW All In, defeating "Speedball" Mike Bailey and Nick Wayne in a hard-fought three-way contest on the August 12 edition of AEW Dynamite. The bout determined who would follow Andrade into the gauntlet, which will crown a number one contender for the AEW World Championship. The title picture is currently set around Kenny Omega's defense against Will Ospreay, meaning the winner of the Casino Gauntlet will face the champion after that clash.

From the opening bell, MJF played a calculated game. He refused to engage directly, instead walking to the commentary table and professing his strategy to let Wayne and Bailey weaken each other so he could pick the bones. Paul Wight, seated at the desk, watched with amusement. MJF eventually returned to the ring, but was quickly sent flying back to the outside by Bailey, allowing the two younger competitors to continue their battle.

Bailey took control, landing a moonsault onto both opponents after dumping Wayne to the floor. MJF, undeterred, climbed toward Wight and asked for assistance, but the commentator took pleasure in refusing him. The action shifted back inside the ring, where Bailey nearly pinned Wayne with a Shooting Star Press, only for Wayne to kick out. Wayne responded with a Prodigy-Plex, seemingly on the verge of victory, but MJF broke the count just before three.

Bailey then delivered Ultima Weapon to Wayne, a move that should have sealed the match. But MJF, who had been lurking on the apron, shoved Bailey off the ring apron and immediately cinched in the Salt of the Earth armbar on Wayne. The submission was deep and unyielding; Wayne had no choice but to tap out, giving MJF the win.

The victory carries significant weight. In the Casino Gauntlet, the order of entry matters—the later entrants face fresher opponents, but the first entrant, Andrade, has the advantage of being in the ring from the start. MJF, entering second, will have to navigate a match that could include up to 21 participants. His cunning and willingness to manipulate the situation, as seen in this match, may prove crucial.

MJF has long positioned himself as a top contender, and this win keeps him firmly in the world title conversation. With Omega and Ospreay set to collide, the gauntlet winner will be waiting. MJF's path to the championship now runs through the Casino Gauntlet, where he will have to outlast a field of hungry competitors. His performance on Dynamite showed he is willing to do whatever it takes to reach the top.