The Detroit Red Wings find themselves at a crossroads with captain Dylan Larkin, whose trade request shook the organization earlier this offseason. What once seemed inevitable—a parting of ways before the 2026-27 NHL season—now carries a thread of uncertainty. A report circulating around the league hints that the Red Wings may still convince their captain to stay, and it all comes down to one critical factor: who they hire to replace Steve Yzerman as general manager.

Detroit faces an urgent timeline. The search for a new GM is under intense scrutiny, with the Larkin saga hanging over every decision. If the Wings land the right candidate, Larkin might think twice before waiving his no-trade clause. As Kevin Weekes put it on Off The Roster, "I think maybe the change in management might—and I'm not speaking for Larkin—but it might change the dynamic a little bit to make him want to stay. I'm not sure that he ends up being traded." The implication is clear: the next GM could be the deciding factor.

Parting ways with Yzerman was a bold move, but the Red Wings are now down to their last bullet if they want to keep Larkin. The organization needs to seal the deal with a hire that inspires confidence. However, retaining Larkin after the offseason turmoil—one that cost the team dearly in terms of reputation and fan trust—may not sit well with the fanbase. The narrative has shifted dramatically.

Most fans in Detroit have turned on Larkin. They feel betrayed by the home-state captain who asked to leave the organization. The sentiment is that there is no going back. Throughout the offseason, it has been made clear time and again: Red Wings fans are returning the favor. Larkin asked out, and the fanbase is no longer counting on him. Even if he changes his mind and decides to stay in Motor City, he will likely be greeted by a hostile crowd when the puck drops. Some fans argue that the team is better with Larkin on the ice, and that is true in a purely hockey sense. But many no longer care. Pride and pettiness have entered the equation. It is no longer about what is best for the organization; it is about feeling wronged.

If Larkin does start the 2026-27 season in Detroit, the pressure will be immense. He could be booed all night long. That hostility might wane over time, but only if the team strings together wins and Larkin plays at the highest level of his career. Staying put means facing a far heavier burden than leaving. It has been a long time since he first asked out, and he has not given the Red Wings many options to facilitate a trade. The time for refunds is over. It appears too late for Larkin to have a change of heart and expect love and mercy from the fans. If he ends up staying, he will have to win them over—one shift, one goal, one victory at a time.