The United States women's basketball team has dominated the international stage for decades, but on a tense Sunday evening in Berlin, they had to dig deeper than any World Cup game in nearly 20 years. Escaping with a 55-52 victory over Italy, the Americans learned that even the most storied programs can be pushed to the brink.

Jackie Young led a sputtering offense with 10 points, but the box score tells only part of the story. The 55 points marked the lowest total for a U.S. win in the World Cup since a 42-38 grind against Australia in 1967. For a team that had won 32 consecutive World Cup games—dating back to a 2006 semifinal loss to Russia—this was uncharted territory.

Italy, playing in its first World Cup since 1994, threw a wrench into the American machine with a disciplined 2-3 zone defense. The U.S. shot just 29% from the field, missed all but one of their 12 three-point attempts, and failed to convert numerous layups. “Obviously, Italy really kind of mucked up the game for us a little bit,” said Breanna Stewart, who missed her first eight shots before scoring the go-ahead basket with less than four minutes to play. “They are a tough team. Tons of respect to what they’ve done.”

The game began as so many U.S. contests do: a dominant first quarter that saw the Americans sprint to a 23-8 lead. But Italy adjusted, switching to a zone that disrupted the U.S. rhythm. The Italians closed the half on a 16-7 run, trimming the deficit to 30-24. They carried that momentum into the third quarter, an 11-2 surge giving them a 35-32 lead. By the fourth, it was 50-48 Italy with 4:29 remaining.

Then came the turning point. Chelsea Gray, known for her savvy, drew a charging foul on Italy's Matilde Villa with 3:03 left, a call Coach Kara Lawson described as “a big momentum-changing play.” Gray followed with a jumper with 1:07 on the clock, pushing the U.S. lead to five. Villa answered to cut the margin to three, but Italy's final chance—a three-pointer by Cecilia Zandalasini at the buzzer—clanked off the rim.

Zandalasini, who led Italy with 14 points, later apologized for her emotional reaction toward an official after the no-call. “I would like to apologize for how I reacted in the end,” she said. “It was a lot of emotions today, but I should have kept them inside of me a little better.”

For the U.S., the narrow escape was a reminder of a shifting landscape. The Americans’ eighth consecutive Olympic gold in 2024 came by a single point against France. “We’ve seen that through the tournament that every game feels like a dogfight,” Lawson said. “It’s really hard. On any given night, if you’re not prepared to play, you’ll lose. That’s awesome for our sport.”

Elsewhere on Sunday, China edged the Czech Republic in overtime, Australia topped Turkey, and Belgium beat Puerto Rico. The U.S. (2-0) will need to recalibrate its offense quickly as the tournament progresses. “You have to be able to win different ways,” Lawson added. “We didn’t have a fastball tonight, but we figured it out late and we’ll grow from it.”